Letter to the Editor: ‘Disappointed’ in coverage
(We at the Review believe in open and civil discourse. In that spirit, we are continuing the long-standing tradition of featuring letters to the editor to allow our readers to express their views in a public forum. We encourage all of our readers to share their opinions with us in this manner.
It should be noted that the opinions and views expressed within these letters are entirely those of the authors, and are not reflective of the opinions and views of the Review.)
Letter to the Editor
We are deeply disappointed in the Washburn Review for the “breaking story” it published last Saturday regarding the incident at a department Halloween party, which is currently being investigated. The first iteration of the story included no on-the-record sources, even while it published the name and photo of the faculty member in question. In our view, this amounts to publicly dragging someone without due process and before the facts are clear.
In order to function properly in a democracy, a free press must abide by a strict code of ethics. The Society of Professional Journalists is one organization that offers guidance to journalists. Off-the-record sources should only be used when (a) the information they provide cannot be obtained elsewhere and (b) the source faces real danger if revealed. Neither was true in this case.
In our clickbait-driven world, rumors and controversy spread fast while facts and logic struggle to catch up. To be clear, we were not present at the event in question and are not expressing any opinions about it, nor are we trying to validate or invalidate the feelings of anyone who was present. Rather, our intention is to remind the Washburn Review that ethical standards for journalism matter because in a democracy, individuals have the right to due process and the right to face their accusers. We all benefit from these rights.
Lindsey M. Ibañez, Ph.D.
Assistant Professor of Sociology
Alexandra R. Klales, PhD, D-ABFA
Associate Professor of Forensic Anthropology
Your donation will support the student journalists of Washburn University. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Disappointed • Nov 7, 2022 at 12:49 pm
I am disappointed in this letter, which is unfairly attacking those student reporters brave enough to bring this story to the attention of the campus community when most people were staying silent. How convenient for the administration that everyone who has been interviewed for the investigation isn’t allowed to talk about this incident anymore. Also, point (a) mentioned in this letter is just wrong. The author of the original article even wrote that they had tried to interview sources but received no responses.